<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving DTD v1.0 20120330//EN" "JATS-journalarchiving.dtd">
<article xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:ali="http://www.niso.org/schemas/ali/1.0">
  <front>
    <article-meta>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>Towards Strategic and Digital Reform in Uzbekistan’s Real Estate Management</article-title>
        <subtitle>Menuju Reformasi Strategis dan Digital dalam Manajemen Real Estat Uzbekistan</subtitle>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group content-type="author">
        <contrib id="person-f489d9f0210db8db28c26fd736121c1a" contrib-type="person" equal-contrib="no" corresp="no" deceased="no">
          <name>
            <surname>Hanis</surname>
            <given-names>Priyanka Anisa</given-names>
          </name>
          <email>hadiah@umsida.ac.id</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-1" />
        </contrib>
        <contrib id="person-73e604db9b9ff6b45ec08d05c7829830" contrib-type="person" equal-contrib="no" corresp="no" deceased="no">
          <name>
            <surname>Fitriyah</surname>
            <given-names>Hadiah</given-names>
          </name>
          <email>hadiah@umsida.ac.id</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-2" />
        </contrib>
      </contrib-group>
      <aff id="aff-1">
        <country>Indonesia</country>
      </aff>
      <aff id="aff-2">
        <country>Indonesia</country>
      </aff>
      <history>
        <date date-type="received" iso-8601-date="2024-10-25">
          <day>25</day>
          <month>10</month>
          <year>2024</year>
        </date>
      </history>
      <abstract />
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body id="body">
    <sec id="heading-5b1722d7bc4f8d18702689edf7802299">
      <title>
        <bold id="_bold-7">Introduction</bold>
      </title>
      <p id="paragraph-e72c29e3100bbae731f79873a55b3ead">In recent years, a number of reforms have been implemented in Uzbekistan to diversify the economy, increase the share of the private sector, and improve the investment climate. The importance of real estate in these processes has increased significantly. This is because real estate is not only a tangible asset but also a strategic resource that stimulates economic activity, generates income for the budget, and ensures the well-being of the population [1].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-10">Real estate objects serve as the main foundation for state institutions, private enterprises, and various social and commercial infrastructures. Therefore, their effective management not only increases the profit from assets but also realizes their full value and ensures social and economic priorities. In particular, the rational use of real estate objects is a crucial factor in urban planning, utilities, education, healthcare, and investment projects [2].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-11">In practice, however, it is observed that many real estate objects are not managed effectively, and their potential is not fully utilized. For example, some state-owned properties remain unused, while private property owners lack sufficient knowledge and methodological guidance on the strategic use of real estate. Such situations lead to decreased resource efficiency, lost opportunities, and suppression of economic activity.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-12">Today, due to the processes of rapid urbanization, expansion of the private sector, and reform of state property in Uzbekistan, the issue of effective management of real estate objects is gaining special importance. Rational management of real estate objects owned by both state and private sectors is crucial not only for increasing their economic benefits but also for ensuring the overall socio-economic development of society [3].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-13">At the same time, numerous practical issues exist: the technical condition of real estate properties is not fully assessed, their operational efficiency is low, profitability levels are insufficient, and in most cases, they are not utilized for strategic purposes. The inadequate implementation of information systems and the fact that management decisions are made based on subjective approaches rather than data also limits overall effectiveness.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-14">From this perspective, it is necessary to radically improve management quality by introducing modern approaches to real estate management, developing specific criteria for evaluating efficiency, utilizing digital technologies, as well as advancing public-private partnership mechanisms. In this process, applying a scientifically grounded, systematic, and comprehensive approach is of paramount importance [4].</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="heading-993a7ec618e3a9333ed49fc9c2b1908e">
      <title>
        <bold id="_bold-8">Literature Review on The Topic</bold>
      </title>
      <p id="paragraph-7575c469bdda6e15a9ea800751a830a7">The issue of real estate management has been extensively studied in global science, with research in this field encompassing legal, financial, organizational, and strategic aspects of management. However, the specific characteristics of each country's economic and legal system, as well as market environment, influence the effectiveness of these scientific approaches [5].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-16">In their research on the formation process of the real estate economy in Uzbekistan, M.J. Yunusov and Sh.U. Ergashev emphasize the importance of correctly defining economic criteria for assessment and management. The authors acknowledge that the lack of a comprehensive and transparent information system in the real estate market and the weakness of legal and organizational mechanisms limit management effectiveness. However, their work does not sufficiently develop specific practical mechanisms for implementing innovative management technologies [6].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-17">W. J. Poorvu, in his work “Real Estate: A Case Study Approach”, analyzes the decision-making process in real estate management and links it to changes in the business environment. In his view, any property should be fully re-evaluated based on the business objectives during its use. However, Poorvu's models do not adequately account for the complexities associated with social effectiveness and state property [7].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-18">M. I. Badmaev emphasizes the importance of risk assessment in making management decisions related to real estate and advocates for the effective use of financial models [8]. He criticizes the inefficient use of state assets and proposes developing mechanisms for their effective transfer to the private sector.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-19">The World Bank's report highlights global issues in the system of state property accounting, asset valuation, and effective management. It emphasizes that in many developing countries, property objects are in a state of “on the balance sheet, but not in the economy” [9]. Therefore, the state should consider real estate objects as a strategic resource and transform them into active investment instruments.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-20">In the “Public Asset Management Framework” document prepared by the international organization IMF, transparency, accountability, and efficiency are defined as the main principles in real estate management. The document provides clear criteria for determining the legal status of assets, digitizing information, and implementing performance indicators [10].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-21">Scientific perspectives in the field of real estate management have been rapidly evolving in recent decades, encompassing strategic, innovative, and institutional aspects of management. In this direction, a number of advanced models have been proposed in global science, and their results are being applied in practice.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-22">In his research, F.F. Batyrshinov proposes analyzing real estate objects from the perspective of socio-economic efficiency. In his opinion, management should assess not only economic benefits but also social impact. He developed a “comprehensive evaluation index” model, which proposes taking into account investment benefits, meeting social needs, and the burden on infrastructure [11].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-23">The study conducted by A. Pagourtzi et al. substantiates multi-criteria approaches (Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, MCDA) in the assessment of real estate objects. The authors emphasize the need for models that simultaneously consider several factors, such as market price, location, infrastructure, environmental conditions, and purpose of use. This approach is especially important for socially significant objects located in city centers [12].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-24">In their works, D. Geltner and N. Miller illuminate real estate investments and the management process from the perspective of portfolio theory. They propose assessing the future revenue potential of each object using cash flow-based valuation models. This approach involves managing real estate as an active asset [13].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-25">A. Aluko, using Nigeria as an example, studied the consequences of ineffective management of state real estate assets and identified institutional shortcomings (lack of information, legal ambiguity, corruption risks) as the primary causes. His findings indicate clear reform directions for transforming state property into profitable assets [14].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-26">M.M. Toshpulatov, in his research, substantiated the necessity of inventorying, evaluating, and transferring state assets to automated information systems. In his view, in current conditions, making information-based management decisions is the main guarantee of efficiency [15].</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-27">These sources do not fully cover certain aspects - particularly the role of digital technologies, indicators of social effectiveness, and issues of minimizing management risks in public-private partnerships. For this reason, there is a significant need for new methodological approaches adapted to the context, filling these gaps in national practice.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="heading-bcd685ce1e07e6dc7fd4841c0c2d3b7b">
      <title>
        <bold id="_bold-9">Methodology</bold>
      </title>
      <p id="_paragraph-29">Such a study refers to a multi-dimensional approach to analyzing the efficiency of real estate management in Uzbekistan, which incorporates both the methods of qualitative and quantitative research. A national statistical data 20182024 is provided as the major source of data and a propensity to use data to analyze property exploitation, digitalization, inclusion of information systems, and attracting investment. The framework of the comparative analysis is utilized to retrieve current performance indicators and contrast them with the recognized best-practice benchmarks. The raw data were obtained based on the professional analysis and industry investigation compiled into the form of comprehensive tables and correlative charts. The formulation of a forecast model predicts the trends of investments until 2030, whereas the correlation coefficients will be used to determine the interdependence of some essential variables, e.g., state and property use ratios, or the rates of the investment life. The research also incorporates the textual analysis of the government action plans on reforms in the legislature, and thus offers a contextual information about the institutional changes which have an impact on the effectiveness of management. The role of digital technologies, strategic planning, and mechanisms of the partnership between the state and businesses in real estate governance is given, in particular. The approach is free of stepwise sub-sectioning and adopts a coherent narrative that connects issues identification, analyze the data, and a model solution. The study fulfils local credibility and international standardizability given that it links empirical findings to global templates such as Public Asset Management Framework developed by IMF, and the advice issued by the World Bank. This combined approach to methodology provides strong support in terms of determining inefficiencies in the field of real estate management, making recommendations that are actionable, and consequently directing further research and policy directions within it.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="heading-239d36f8c62ea4c2f8a51b8ab966a5df">
      <title>
        <bold id="_bold-10">Analysis and Results</bold>
      </title>
      <p id="paragraph-3050f65aed5fe2512095bb91af0a7edc">The issue of effective management of real estate assets is one of the pressing topics both globally and in Uzbekistan. Against the backdrop of increasing economic growth rates, the expansion of urbanization processes, the optimization of state assets, and the intensification of privatization policies, the strategic importance of real estate is further increasing.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-31">In recent years, economic reforms implemented in Uzbekistan, political initiatives aimed at effective management of state property, public-private partnership (PPP) projects, and measures to improve the investment climate have necessitated increasing the management efficiency of real estate properties. The government's decisions “On Improving the Management of State Property” and the laws “On Land and Real Estate” indicate the need for a systematic approach in this area.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-32">A real estate property is not just a tangible asset, but an asset that can be transformed into active economic activity. If managed effectively, it can generate higher incomes for both public and private sectors, create new jobs, increase tax revenues, and improve the quality of social services. If neglected, however, it loses its value, brings no profit, and can become a source of excessive expenses (Table 1).</p>
      <table-wrap id="_table-figure-1">
        <label>Table 1</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Analysis of the management status of real estate properties</title>
          <p id="_paragraph-35" />
        </caption>
        <table id="_table-1">
          <tbody>
            <tr id="table-row-76871f946f81a65e0d13bc1c262ff5ed">
              <th id="table-cell-eca38cc50c7c15474e6e0638f07f3d5d">No</th>
              <th id="table-cell-f79fdb453ca5bce3544f477cd1b72bc2">Problem</th>
              <th id="table-cell-23429872de612ca2275da9cf52421efb">Current status (in percent)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-a0545b6f966de2e1f4fa5782914cce4d">Effective management standard (in percent)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-1d79f9f66d42ac9742c76df32e88a7fd">Difference (in percent)</th>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-6eb1fc11449713b62f73066203d396ff">
              <td id="table-cell-a90bd7b498f2887861c8693cedd8e4e7">1</td>
              <td id="table-cell-04cb27cfa379ab9efc13a728e7856009">Vacancy of real estate properties</td>
              <td id="table-cell-1a4c512de81667d101b616b9e0f198cf">38</td>
              <td id="table-cell-8ef1696103a91c4d5238f18772fd7d5b">10</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b4a52ff946bb42da7819fc12ca0027ba">28</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-6489b16b57d4cd08c0a1250035933ee0">
              <td id="table-cell-34251f03c173d5af2b47b64000cea235">2</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d8f125c356e8de63ca60adfbbc231d1a">Lack of a comprehensive information system</td>
              <td id="table-cell-28839a2f1d5ca3efe4554f00e9bea1c9">62</td>
              <td id="table-cell-ac793018f4d6045c4402a01458b22f76">20</td>
              <td id="table-cell-4584b9f30b7c1a6fdc37863ed2eec2b9">42</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-e3c920e0fc19a430f08d618f2d7105a3">
              <td id="table-cell-06c99672b01b4b5bcb0c3a21017984f0">3</td>
              <td id="table-cell-7f8707d6f45ff7b6bd101619db22ebf5">Unclear criteria for evaluating usage efficiency</td>
              <td id="table-cell-61ece35bf638b755ff3a50752750defb">75</td>
              <td id="table-cell-16b5a1d24eff4503d123399963a8cd8f">25</td>
              <td id="table-cell-05e6b244950a61cfcd60a56750ce82f5">50</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-d7ccb1568b2b317534780231a0042027">
              <td id="table-cell-a4f2cb600a4db42378bfb604577bc6d0">4</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d2015709e04742e4683e3e9e5aff800d">Lack of digital management technologies</td>
              <td id="table-cell-943d8606fee33fdcfa8e99d9e4dcf186">68</td>
              <td id="table-cell-cd8f65c1ee0dc122d896a127f9170de3">30</td>
              <td id="table-cell-80cc3d6d2a8cebfae8e536745a75c2b0">38</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-2702dd29e18e92cb46f5b08858da9c61">
              <td id="table-cell-4bcdbca64ebc37d249c779940a1d278a">5</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b36274cacdb25e39e589c7a64ae34649">Low management skills or lack of specialists in the private sector</td>
              <td id="table-cell-fe41467d0af20f28cba812987fa08747">54</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d306042eaee6a375cb8ba48b72509f8e">20</td>
              <td id="table-cell-2a5ad24b429bd7af997c20bf5cafa121">34</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p id="_paragraph-36">Source: Developed by the author based on research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-37">Analysis of the data in Table 1 reveals that the state of real estate management in Uzbekistan shows several systemic problems in the industry's development, which seriously hinder management efficiency. As evident from the table, in many cases, the current situation shows a significant difference compared to ideal management models.</p>
      <list list-type="order" id="list-d89565aa72e04e8c1742ddd1df0facb7">
        <list-item>
          <p>Vacancy of real estate properties. According to the analysis, at least 38% of properties are currently not actively used. In effective management, this indicator should be around 10%. This represents a 28% difference. Such a situation leads to loss of budget revenues and waste of infrastructure resources.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Lack of a comprehensive information system. In 62% of cases, real estate data is scattered and not reflected in the information system. This leads to a lack of transparency in management and the adoption of incorrect decisions. In effective management, this indicator should not exceed 20%, meaning the difference is 42%.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Ambiguity of criteria for evaluating usage efficiency. This problem is observed in 75% of cases, meaning properties are not being evaluated based on their real economic, social, or environmental impact. In best practice, this indicator should not exceed 25%, resulting in a difference of 50%.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Lack of digital management technologies. Digital solutions are absent in 68% of management cases, and there are no automated assessment and monitoring systems. In an effective system, this indicator should be around 30%, meaning there is a 38% gap.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Low management skills in the private sector. In 54% of cases, private property owners and tenants are unable to manage real estate as a strategic resource. This indicator should be 20% in practice, meaning there is a 34% gap.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p id="_paragraph-38">High results can be achieved through systemic reforms in real estate management, digitalization, capacity building, and standardization of valuation mechanisms. This is an important factor ensuring not only economic but also social stability (Table 2).</p>
      <table-wrap id="_table-figure-2">
        <label>Table 2</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Status of management indicators for real estate utilization</title>
          <p id="_paragraph-41" />
        </caption>
        <table id="_table-2">
          <tbody>
            <tr id="table-row-4be684ec37c16bfebfc48ac64f3c0298">
              <th id="table-cell-1277b7bc0f4885399e73a3f8271abd07">No</th>
              <th id="table-cell-d02bb11f8e36ffb2836a3c994a35b100">Years</th>
              <th id="table-cell-d844c2422ac938b5508c85e345d6cf42">Vacant properties (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-07dac646a911121f1887d4b465ecc3b8">Digitalized properties (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-c2d69518a72e4a10e6397d934e46a5dc">Utilization efficiency (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-663bbb4b4a64413ceb4c602066df6ec7">Covered in the information system (%)</th>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-3ddd920485587d1897bfccd72dc2d9c1">
              <td id="table-cell-65417f093fcec4c3b41a62a6536220ee">1</td>
              <td id="table-cell-8166171fd2b7c56a6189ae8c5ab6852c">2018</td>
              <td id="table-cell-2346ac6f07569ce2221e317d9c590a31">42</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a9bfcdba7d3e8285a545abe487f67190">12</td>
              <td id="table-cell-658ecf1797c2537966d51e9a9617230a">48</td>
              <td id="table-cell-26d9cd4e0e6988569749035b2576f363">25</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-c0a85b512fb427d6fefec8c15687de62">
              <td id="table-cell-cd92210edf55f14bf8e4726d6e6a94e3">2</td>
              <td id="table-cell-02150df68f8b63671c80e9fdde02dfda">2019</td>
              <td id="table-cell-c4ad7dfb312dafbd45ef7109528f4529">40</td>
              <td id="table-cell-cd42be07137daab3332e95978da3b49a">15</td>
              <td id="table-cell-8a5c10144a52a14731e854c2b00d5b9a">50</td>
              <td id="table-cell-7c41338274a250e0ce03568958b0175e">30</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-a1ca849272b434e6ef0bc0410106677a">
              <td id="table-cell-7d6680cdd2f2a1441935b98b29b9b828">3</td>
              <td id="table-cell-86697d2158620b2558db9212ea2c545f">2020</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a3a2d97b16276c83a2d13473338556e7">39</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b4f1c89a95b5552d456d907440fa76d7">20</td>
              <td id="table-cell-e762c013fd1a838cc4a61e1940dc6c13">52</td>
              <td id="table-cell-bc8237b368fb7d09fba38520a1b7f468">36</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-7255744ab2726fe28f30d856fbd1787d">
              <td id="table-cell-18dc2d5aeeec7963646f1dc2c4103e47">4</td>
              <td id="table-cell-4ae7604a8a957e7511e95d2b64914760">2021</td>
              <td id="table-cell-ce5582373dee480af00a037576498de7">37</td>
              <td id="table-cell-18a182d33163528d8abc985ec32570f6">28</td>
              <td id="table-cell-6f4edbddfd4d433534c4dd5f43006f85">55</td>
              <td id="table-cell-3021a66c397f18ad07d1e2e62abcd6ac">43</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-fcc8287bfc8d50d33432ef27aef10ee2">
              <td id="table-cell-a7e7c77206dd77a52808e4ae31d51614">5</td>
              <td id="table-cell-8d3f59538f3a3b6c7835f0f3da5a73d7">2022</td>
              <td id="table-cell-c780ff6c67d810f360f8f12941584fe7">35</td>
              <td id="table-cell-6d92b0741f0b63c40466387b065455f9">36</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b3f36f30d11e3a96d6b9599198dc5e0c">59</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a489f98261d408dfa371406b596fb2d9">51</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-de70603b0a3b22b6e3a72d75912dc7b0">
              <td id="table-cell-0f28757ac032cf0a24f3d6d4b0d1d3e6">6</td>
              <td id="table-cell-5c0316f1d584c718d8e69fbbee2dfddb">2023</td>
              <td id="table-cell-bfa0009375023323dff2a8e5c3594544">33</td>
              <td id="table-cell-03123178a21d3587e501bc3612944594">45</td>
              <td id="table-cell-170ed121e0018f0f2cb56d3b5649e1ee">63</td>
              <td id="table-cell-de745b5ab1c9cf0080df6c71f1b353b9">58</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-96ac7ded3bd4dd031ea7a67aedd5d3f3">
              <td id="table-cell-9bcd0ad447e4a6a75373f34177407369">7</td>
              <td id="table-cell-1f947b10d44ffe15911109b83e1637f3">2024</td>
              <td id="table-cell-af4ace8bae52bba44a997ea92c99a5b6">31</td>
              <td id="table-cell-706703cf0b51ea677df26f977dd0a9bc">53</td>
              <td id="table-cell-5e02a3945e93448ed42fe78d3e852844">67</td>
              <td id="table-cell-c2426d1b9d42d4a050fdcc9f90e19315">66</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p id="_paragraph-42">Source: Developed by the author based on research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-43">Based on the real estate management indicators for 2018-2024 presented in Table 2 above, the following analytical conclusions can be drawn:</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-44">1. Regarding vacant properties, 42% of facilities in both public and private sectors were not actually utilized in 2018. By 2024, this figure had decreased to 31%. This shows positive dynamics (+11% improvement), however, one in three properties is still not involved in economic activity.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-45">2. Regarding digitized properties, in 2018, only 12% of all properties were digitized. In 2024, this figure reached 53%. This area has seen the fastest growth - a total increase of 41%. This paves the way for a transition to information-based management decisions.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-46">3. In terms of utilization efficiency, if in 2018 it was around 48%, by 2024 this indicator reached 67%. This represents a 19% increase, indicating a rise in profits and productivity from real estate.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-47">4. Regarding coverage in the information system, in 2018 only 25% of real estate properties were registered in the electronic information system, while in 2024 this figure is 66%. This represents a 41% increase, meaning the possibilities for active management in the digital environment are expanding.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-48">In Uzbekistan, between 2018 and 2024, systemic reforms were implemented in the real estate management sector. This was especially evident in the digitalization and implementation of information systems. However, the proportion of idle properties and the still high problematic indicators in management effectiveness remain key areas requiring further solutions (Table 3).</p>
      <table-wrap id="_table-figure-3">
        <label>Table 3</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Status of real estate utilization indicators</title>
          <p id="_paragraph-51" />
        </caption>
        <table id="_table-3">
          <tbody>
            <tr id="table-row-56e5ffc1423191009f487d9d901a7e36">
              <th id="table-cell-40a17a114a479bc246ba95d26877a2ad">No.</th>
              <th id="table-cell-c4067c17babc70d26855a577b0b6a138">Years</th>
              <th id="table-cell-23d4dd05655a1323fa5742b99e7524c8">Level of state property utilization (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-6cc7270baf1d9e62aac6fd2113ec46b0">Level of private property utilization (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-826b1cdd3be4bf9fb6b4323d809e5405">Investment-attracted objects (%)</th>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-1af351af54a5f53c92f164da64ddda17">
              <td id="table-cell-0513b00ae17c7a907466ac50d6a1a6d3">1</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f9ebfd7c651e384b2996f1270dd14928">2018</td>
              <td id="table-cell-bb33f43548793b9da9db2c8e8f1fdaec">44</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b6a08620a7f3945308452ab479bd96e3">61</td>
              <td id="table-cell-e2bdb8a324978c824cfb54ae1dded16f">18</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-6b00c169ee387b22c4a7a018f5b1298a">
              <td id="table-cell-04ea5f216e5dfbb3a66ecd49aa6eae61">2</td>
              <td id="table-cell-e479409cdb3c930c0cc25a36fa006834">2019</td>
              <td id="table-cell-ebde29979e3c832734726ddeb208bfb4">46</td>
              <td id="table-cell-54895da650b1c92fa0e57333da328316">63</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a4a3323a519b5c3fb661198618f51abb">21</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-f1dd33b8f2acabade48920741693232f">
              <td id="table-cell-f23b66d174d2ce59f83f3e8b84b8d56e">3</td>
              <td id="table-cell-92734a4981d57eb682dfbab2a932e356">2020</td>
              <td id="table-cell-9abdf8cda85333ef10117e70334ce831">49</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a19b4c291163bacc3112092e9cb385df">65</td>
              <td id="table-cell-7c1506b6f515a83cb4c4ad4163f19e22">24</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-4f7e465c7d30b30b43f0b2cef43c052e">
              <td id="table-cell-05250648122618ac70ffdf5362f8fa06">4</td>
              <td id="table-cell-6849ab1402329ffc453551015fd489da">2021</td>
              <td id="table-cell-8f75ba3e5a92cb93f450dd2007df613f">52</td>
              <td id="table-cell-186323caa2f6f98613244795e1151b4f">67</td>
              <td id="table-cell-979efe12fd5fed8015a0b8b7f237142f">28</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-48d0246ed22d5389aff76e3bb6448bff">
              <td id="table-cell-683c5564f88124665110376f3a463178">5</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b57da879d65d643d255d921b154b3401">2022</td>
              <td id="table-cell-b6b24e600c583b173da0ef8eb04f4a01">56</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f8d172805847bcb7c859352bf39f6115">70</td>
              <td id="table-cell-81e5e08d399f6e5a7bb91d78c34c46b8">33</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-8c6280f9d155baee9efa47fa2980a3ba">
              <td id="table-cell-010d29e12e55e1cae623d78bfc78edd6">6</td>
              <td id="table-cell-9c6835e5dabb2661c9ef8ad8e6e942e8">2023</td>
              <td id="table-cell-91dc6885f6e492c422afaedad4e4ccc5">60</td>
              <td id="table-cell-67a5e80a7b493af0df39f35aeb234927">72</td>
              <td id="table-cell-4ff90d6f893b955e968b35e02b014579">39</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-2523b367a8a57f2830e15098d97d0617">
              <td id="table-cell-a8727604f4aa071290bbbac6a0028630">7</td>
              <td id="table-cell-ece2edeb9cf1f2577a0b234d1275547c">2024</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f9aec429621a576e3bf7a3064f3da519">65</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a0efca5750ec7c39a30f30251e8f80f6">75</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f4487fcafe974fd2596c494acaf3ce3e">45</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p id="_paragraph-52">Source: Developed by the author based on research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-53">According to the data in Table 3, analysis of property utilization levels (state and private sector) shows that the level of state property utilization increased from 44% in 2018 to 65% in 2024. This positive growth (21%) indicates increased involvement of state objects in economic activity. The utilization level of private property objects is also high - rising from 61% in 2018 to 75% in 2024. This suggests superior management skills and market instincts in the private sector. Regarding investment-attracted objects, the investment activity indicator increased from 18% in 2018 to 45% in 2024. This particularly demonstrates the development of public-private partnership (PPP) mechanisms and the transformation of property objects into investment resources (Table 4).</p>
      <table-wrap id="_table-figure-4">
        <label>Table 4</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Factors of inefficiency in real estate management</title>
          <p id="_paragraph-56" />
        </caption>
        <table id="_table-4">
          <tbody>
            <tr id="table-row-de3bfcff7b3d47d0038a50c6b4f8f1cf">
              <th id="table-cell-78cdbbcc6e2905d5549cd167e08b7bc1">No.</th>
              <th id="table-cell-4bc24dfe0f75757ca3bca1db278e674f">Years</th>
              <th id="table-cell-85cc857865bc5317401c42ce79b179ef">Cases of ineffective management (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-2e34460c9377fa074d50f2c1e6a7261f">Unrevalued assets (%)</th>
              <th id="table-cell-2bb7f324d38264685fcd23ec59643671">Cases in legal disputes (%)</th>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-80bc0688acca6adbbed402074c4ddd6f">
              <td id="table-cell-aca7b5290b4a21d1dee7f45340b6c0d5">1</td>
              <td id="table-cell-67d1c698dac683646dea8e9086371c69">2018</td>
              <td id="table-cell-54f442cdc6ff3655a1fdd98d9de62b8f">36</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f583cf89c867cb485c1f97d652963dd1">58</td>
              <td id="table-cell-5372d7857ec99a59d711059666276b39">14</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-a7347c70617669fcc37b74964811cd29">
              <td id="table-cell-1f57e6a8e334ca257b85bccefd3ce9e1">2</td>
              <td id="table-cell-1f686cf729cc6264fc4a48667eb50d71">2019</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d7af98a2342779d48e4e5be03cf91863">35</td>
              <td id="table-cell-1d340376c0e270e4f4b692044dca32d2">55</td>
              <td id="table-cell-db6501283658285047246685f424dd32">15</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-ea4c1c224d25154286a6a7316239f26d">
              <td id="table-cell-8c35cdc9204adf5fc1991e91859445ca">3</td>
              <td id="table-cell-7594b9c0f4dcf199387a5b655f0db0d0">2020</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f5b4b2f661d4665083d46ed20eabd846">34</td>
              <td id="table-cell-cf4ffd0628762c84149f905fa8a9d190">51</td>
              <td id="table-cell-3b324ecaf08923081dab2337089832ad">13</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-6e883821fa0e98e35e7ed29583a129c0">
              <td id="table-cell-99cead8b3f236228219428c58921a45e">4</td>
              <td id="table-cell-9522a42ef29bf74232b77080964e682e">2021</td>
              <td id="table-cell-3f6be586db5c8d27fe20d3cbe1dfdcd8">32</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d0890da9542af262af92aca0ba2c29ed">46</td>
              <td id="table-cell-aef5c05b80555da247fb9a41cb59cf5f">12</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-29e3e8f6218bed4fc90d4199cb900785">
              <td id="table-cell-08242032a829d534c9eadca417daa74f">5</td>
              <td id="table-cell-bae4aa24a129a0a0b3c1e96e6bc0abcd">2022</td>
              <td id="table-cell-02e323009763a20e5e127e69f268851b">30</td>
              <td id="table-cell-6608e4cd9ec3e4bba33bee16e005c8f7">40</td>
              <td id="table-cell-f39762a5253b6b4c527821b197609a1f">11</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-c569c88951b3141bf2474a961643b985">
              <td id="table-cell-6ade4356c51aa3faa9d3025cf5717b70">6</td>
              <td id="table-cell-a84f569910f3a45dc8d6774b54df4661">2023</td>
              <td id="table-cell-c89e91c8da751d2d5df7b3edd315b75e">27</td>
              <td id="table-cell-28e9fdcf42f5809fd61d8f955fdd5968">35</td>
              <td id="table-cell-43057f9838debc3673d6184a981f3654">10</td>
            </tr>
            <tr id="table-row-6c903e0c2de34fe82b3d8da4f65ebaa5">
              <td id="table-cell-48181a5c812497320e01afe5cda863a2">7</td>
              <td id="table-cell-85bd8f9ba26ffcd25588685ecd4dc984">2024</td>
              <td id="table-cell-887870966a63b9ab296ee50b9b20c0f0">25</td>
              <td id="table-cell-60feb11ba42bad0714d59ebae3673e03">29</td>
              <td id="table-cell-d22e6fa7f009ffc126c3b80e7862fe8a">9</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p id="_paragraph-57">Source: Developed by the author based on research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-58">According to the data in Table 4, regarding factors of inefficiency in management, cases of inefficiency in management amounted to 36% in 2018. This indicator has decreased over the years, dropping to 25% in 2024. This reflects the positive impact of systemic reforms and digitalization processes. Concerning non-revalued assets, it was 58% in 2018. This means that this percentage of assets had not yet been revalued at market value. In 2024, this figure dropped to 29%, indicating the process has improved twofold. This will serve to clarify the property base and increase financial transparency. As for properties involved in legal disputes, the share of property that was the subject of legal disputes decreased from 14% in 2018 to 9% in 2024. This indicates the strengthening of the legal framework and the expansion of opportunities for institutional resolution of property-related disputes.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-59">Based on the above data, a correlation analysis of real estate utilization indicators and a forecast for investment attraction in real estate objects for 2018-2030 were developed.</p>
      <fig id="figure-panel-722672f0c94a372c810c854a080154bd">
        <label>Figure 1</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Correlation state between real estate utilization indicators</title>
          <p id="paragraph-5b4f30bf3df5c21176506f7fa26178d3" />
        </caption>
        <graphic id="graphic-aee2e8dbe760d378df4f9e7afb4b4e50" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="Picture 1.png" />
      </fig>
      <p id="_paragraph-61">Source: Developed by the author based on the research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-62">Figure 1 presents the “correlation between real estate utilization indicators”. Based on this correlation map, the following conclusions can be drawn: the indicator of investment attraction (%) has a high positive correlation with state and private property (%); it can be observed that the indicator of private property (%) in management is increasing correspondingly with state property (%).</p>
      <fig id="figure-panel-d39146e3443608615830911e9d08e0d9">
        <label>Figure 2</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Investment attraction for real estate objects: forecast for 2018-2030</title>
          <p id="paragraph-599908339ce3be84b35e2692deb6ba2c" />
        </caption>
        <graphic id="graphic-a80ecbef48dec8a2c61c9a1c91d4a143" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="Picture 2.png" />
      </fig>
      <p id="_paragraph-64">Source: Developed by the author based on the research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-65">As evident from Figure 2, the level of investment attraction demonstrates a stable growth trend: 47.71% in 2025, 52.21% in 2026, 56.71% in 2027, 61.21% in 2028, 65.71% in 2029, and 70.2% in 2030. If the current pace of reforms and digitalization is maintained, by 2030 more than 70% of real estate objects could be involved in investment activities. This will have a positive impact on the state budget, employment, and local infrastructure.</p>
      <fig id="figure-panel-ba96ebee9b946c29bd4f389a7c33e88b">
        <label>Figure 3</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Scheme for improving the efficiency of real estate management</title>
          <p id="paragraph-bf5594aedfdab45a001c04b691fb60ef" />
        </caption>
        <graphic id="graphic-334fa11942b44a1f8a47aef5a30450d9" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="Picture 3.png" />
      </fig>
      <p id="_paragraph-67">Source: Developed by the author based on the research results.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-68">The figure above visually represents the main elements of the topic “Improving the efficiency of real estate management” and their interrelationships:</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-69">1. Central point: Real Estate Management Efficiency;</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-70">2. The main factors supporting it: digitalization, strategic planning, public-private partnership;</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-71">3. As their result: information system, investment, social analysis, human resources, legal framework;</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-72">4. Finally: effective management outcomes.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-73">Currently, thousands of real estate properties in the republic are lying idle and being used inefficiently. Information about them is insufficient, and a clear strategy for renovation, reconstruction, or sale has not been developed. At the same time, many entities in the private sector are operating with diminished investment potential. This situation leads to a decrease in economic efficiency, freezing of capital, and loss of opportunities.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-74">Therefore, the relevance of the topic is as follows:</p>
      <list list-type="order" id="list-cc7e8d23e912a247fd1cf69f09d7dd1f">
        <list-item>
          <p>Proper management of state assets contributes to the stability of the national economy;</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Improvement of the investment climate is closely linked to the rational use of real estate;</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>The development of urban infrastructure depends on the strategy for real estate properties;</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>In the era of digital transformation, the digitalization of management mechanisms is required.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p id="_paragraph-75">From this perspective, fundamentally improving real estate management, proposing concrete solutions to existing problems, and applying best practices in the national context is one of today's urgent tasks.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="heading-ebf62ca2cd8b7addce00ea630cf436cc">
      <title>
        <bold id="_bold-50">Conclusion</bold>
      </title>
      <p id="paragraph-ccdeea2d98bfb28e121178c7daaa4f9f">Effective management of real estate is not merely the utilization of assets, but a crucial direction for developing the national economy, ensuring financial stability, improving citizens' quality of life, and increasing the level of regional development.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-77">This research and analysis have shown that during 2018-2024, a number of positive changes were implemented in the real estate management system. Specifically: the processes of informatization and digitalization have accelerated; the indicator of investment attraction has increased sharply; optimization in the use of state property has been observed; and cases of ineffective management and legal disputes have decreased.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-78">However, at the same time, the problems revealed by the analysis necessitate a new stage of reforms in this area. That is, existing infrastructural and institutional problems cannot be solved with short-term reforms. This process requires a systematic, scientifically-based, and multi-stage approach.</p>
      <list list-type="order" id="list-ece707dce1f8962a5216ca321c62f5bd">
        <list-item>
          <p>It is necessary to fully implement digital transformation. A unified interactive platform should clearly reflect the complete register of real estate objects, their legal status, value, condition, and intended purposes of use. Through this, the real value and investment attractiveness of the property can be assessed.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Property objects need to be redirected as strategic resources. Each object should be analyzed not only in terms of rental income but also in connection with urban planning, demographics, economic activity, and transport infrastructure.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>It is necessary to establish a management system that takes into account social and regional balance. Along with high-demand properties in Tashkent and major cities, mechanisms should be developed to actively integrate property objects from underdeveloped regions into economic circulation.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Personnel training and management culture need to be fundamentally renewed. Specialists working in the real estate sector should be trained through a system of education, retraining, and certification based on international standards. Management depends not only on legal or financial knowledge but also on personnel with strategic thinking abilities.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>Mechanisms of institutional cooperation and public-private partnership need to be revised. Currently, existing partnership projects do not fully reflect the potential. PPP models based on principles of a favorable legal and financial environment for investors, transparency and benefits for the public, and efficiency for the state are required.</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>To assess management effectiveness, it is necessary to develop national indices. Through the “Real Estate Management Efficiency Index”, which can be published annually, the activities of various ministries, local governments, commercial organizations, and the private sector can be evaluated.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p id="_paragraph-79">Real estate management should be considered not only as an economic resource for the national economy today but also as a key to state stability, investment attractiveness, and social development. If the analysis and proposals presented in this article are implemented in practice, the real estate management system in Uzbekistan will reach a level that meets not only the needs of the domestic market but also international investment standards.</p>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back />
</article>